To Forgive or Not Forgive, That is the Question

Ellamae learned how to ride her bike this week. It was the coolest thing ever. Her older sister, Grace, actually taught her and when Ellamae saw me, she couldn't wait to show me in person how she could ride her bike all by herself. We were all so proud of her, but no one was more proud of her than her own self. And Ellamae loves a good surprise. So I should have realized that she would want to surprise her dad by showing him in person like she did me. But I didn't and I sent him the video her sister took of her first ride. I told Ellamae that I was really, really sorry that I had ruined her surprise. She just laughed and told me it was okay because she can never stay mad at me. What a beautiful heart.

Wouldn't it be great if forgiveness always came so easily and was given so freely? The other day, something happened that made me ask myself if I've forgiven my ex-husband. Truthfully, I don't know. Because for me, forgiveness is a matter of the heart, not the head. I can't just flip a switch and decide to forgive someone. I just can't. Maybe that isn't how forgiveness works for others, or how we're taught it's supposed to be. We should forgive, right? We have received the gift of grace and we forgive others because who among us isn't in need of forgiveness? I actually believe that. But forgiveness is a journey. And it's a journey my heart takes and I can't think my way through that one.

I got triggered the other day and all the hard work of the past two and a half years disappeared in an instant. I found myself transported to that awful place where doubt and insecurity reign supreme. I was scared and mistrusting. The pain hurt just as much as it did in the past. I was confused and caught in a space where I couldn't separate the past from the present. It was just for a moment, and my fear was met with patience and understanding that was rooted in love and acceptance. It helped me find my way back.

But I was filled with a hate for everything he did to hurt me and that it still has the power to haunt me. There are times that I get so mad remembering the pieces of my soul that were ripped from me and the holes that were left in my heart. Raging mad. I-hate-you mad and I-don't-even-have-the-desire-to-forgive mad. In those moments I would emphatically declare without hesitation that no, I have unequivocally not forgiven him.

Forgiveness is messy business. I know that forgiveness sets you free. Holding onto anger is like holding onto a corrosive poison. Because when that anger resurfaces it always comes with it's unwanted companion, pain. But that's where I find myself these days; somewhere along the fluid spectrum of an inability to forgive and the freedom of forgiveness.

And I'm okay with that.

To forgive or not forgive, that is not the question. It's not an intellectual decision dictated by what I think I should do. I think "shoulds" do not apply to forgiveness because there's an obligatory component to "should". If that's the case, how can forgiveness be freely given?

I know myself well enough to know that I will forgive. I've been on this journey before. I know that just as love brought me back from the past, grace will lead me to forgiveness. But if you're like me and struggling to forgive, I think that's okay. We're just on another leg of the journey. Don't force it, just let it come. Let your heart find the way and trust in it's timing. In the meantime, find rest in the arms of grace. Don't let the weight of an expectation of yourself to forgive steal the peace that you've found. Because I think that when our hearts are strong enough, when love and grace have mended the holes, there won't be room for that anger and we'll find that we can let it go.

Join me in that hope and let's walk this leg of the journey together.

Comments

Dear Grace

Dear Grace, Happy 12th birthday!!! I know I usually write a list of reasons telling you why I love you on your birthday, but as you approach your twelfth year I can't help but notice how independent you are becoming. Time is flying by and before I know it, you will be a young woman. So here we are... I'm trying to step back and let you stretch your wings more and you're busy going about the business of becoming the beautiful young woman I know you will be. How I wish I could freeze this moment in time and keep you my little girl forever. But time doesn't listen to the pleadings of a mother's heart and keeps marching on. So this year, I want to do something different. I want to make you a list of 12 things I hope you will always remember and keep in your heart as your journey through life continues. 1. I love you, forever and always. You are my joy and no matter what, I will always love you. 2. You are enough. There may be times in life w

Dear Kind Friend

I struggle with depression. To the point that two years ago I was hospitalized three times in the span of six months, each admission lasting 10-14 days. That was when my depression was untreated and at its worst. It was so debilitating that I had to take a year off of work just to get my feet grounded and start functioning again. Two years later, I have come so far, but I'm still learning how to live with this. At this time in my journey I have to be intentional about staying present in the moment, disciplining my thoughts, and making healthy mental and spiritual choices - each and every day. One of the hardest things about depression is trying to reach through that thick cloud of despair to find my strongest self and summon her forth. If even a tiny piece of her had a voice, this is what she would've said to you. This is how she would have asked for help. To my tribe that has endlessly stood by my side through it all, thank you for listening to her when I had no word

The Monster in My Basement

I want to tell my story. I need to tell my story. To speak it aloud and release the shame and regret I feel. To absolve myself of the responsibility I have taken for other's actions. To learn how to live with my past decisions. To discover how my past is a part of me and shaping me, not ruining me. Because even though I am moving forward, I feel stuck. When my kids were growing up, I would read them this book where a boy saw a monster in the basement. His mother was busy in the garden and didn't believe him, so he tackled the monster himself. At first the monster was a looming presence, but with each swipe of a broom and words of bravery, the monster shrunk. And shrunk, until it was just a tiny little guy, no bigger than the size of a mouse. The monster, realizing he could no longer scare the boy, ran away and the boy had nothing left to fear. My story is my monster. And speaking it aloud is how I face it, shrink it, until there is nothing left to fear from it. N

What if...

I just took all three of my kids for their annual physical and there's nothing like a plot on a growth chart to remind me of how fast they are growing. Time just keeps marching on, and at my urging, all those vegetable and fruits they consume are doing their job. They are growing. Sometimes it feels as if these days of their childhood are just slipping through my fingers, like grains of sand that I can't keep from finding their way through the cracks in my hands. My middle daughter is having a hard time. She's going to make it, I know she will. She's tough and she's loved - it's just the getting through it that's hard. Tonight she asked me to lay with her until she fell asleep and I found myself staring at her; all 46 inches of her curled up next to me, chest rising and falling in a deep fresh air induced sleep, skin bronzed and kissed by the sun. She was the picture of childhood and summer days. She even smelled like the sun and the pool and a fr

Be Amazing, Fantastically Amazing

I am an amazing Mom. Not pretty amazing, more along the lines of fantastically amazing. My house is a mess. There is dog hair everywhere and toys in - Every. Single. Room. Laundry is done on a strictly need-to-do basis only. Four kids later, I'm rockin' the "Mom Bod" hard core. I co-sleep with my 4 year old, and have no plans of stopping any time soon, just don't have the fight in me at the end of the day. I won't drop her afternoon nap because I need one too. When I come home from working a midnight shift, I put on cartoons and give the 4 year old my phone and let her go nuts for 2-3 hours while I sleep on the couch. Because of my work/sleep schedule, I rarely volunteer in my kids' classrooms. I don't buy them brand name clothes, I'm too cheap. I haven't taken a family portrait since the baby was born (she's the 4 year old), so I only have three of my four kids immortalized in a professional photo. My go-to meal is frozen chick

Pandemic Thoughts from a 14 Year Old

I have wanted to write about this pandemic for some time now. But I can't find the words. They elude me and I can't put together my thoughts and feelings. From day to day, I vacillate between fear and hope and a gamut of feelings in between. My focus has been on my job as a nurse, making sure my kids are emotionally nurtured, and protecting those I love by doing what I can to make it possible for them to stay home and out of danger. I'm too scared to focus on more than that. But this morning, my daughter Grace shared this journal entry she had written for a social studies project she's working on. And once again, I found myself at a loss for words. She succinctly captured this crazy, turned upside down time with a simplicity and clarity that cut through the extraneous and hit right at the heart of it all. An authentic uncensored mix of grief, anger, frustration, compassion and hope from the heart of a 14 year old girl. I'll let her words speak to you -

Grace

My little girl is so sad. Deep, from the gut, sad. She is always missing someone. In the moment, it is whoever isn't there - either Mom or Dad. But really, I think she misses the family we once were. The wholeness of the unit. The complete picture. "Can you find a picture of 'The Five of Us'?" To keep under your pillow next to your baby album full of pictures of your Dad and I beaming as we stare in wonder at the miracle of you, beautiful you? Sure, baby. Of course. I can see the memories of "us" beginning to fade and slip through her fingers. Like the image of a loved ones' face starting to fade with time... And no matter how tight you squeeze your eyes shut and ball up your fists, you just can't make your brain recall the image in focus. And all you're left with is a fuzzy blur that seems more like a feeling than a memory leaving you wondering - was it ever real? "Mom, did you ever come to the cabin with us? Have you ev

Bird Tattoo

I got a tattoo. A huge tattoo. It was about as impulsive as I get, which means - I let it percolate in the back of my mind for about a year, then researched it for about a month, then made an appointment with the tattoo guy - and impulsively (ahhh, that's where it works itself in!) got the outline done on Design Day as opposed to 2 weeks later when I had actually scheduled Tattoo Day... that's me living on the edge. I got a phoenix on my back. I told Mr. Tattoo Man that I wanted a phoenix with its head up, wings out, ready to fly. I wanted it to look strong, but beautiful - and it does, just like me. Up from the ashes, ready to fly. Part of me loves the fact that looking at me, and even knowing me, one would never think I would have this gigantic bird on my back - make no mistake, it's freaking huge. Part of me loves the fact that I was able to lay on a tattoo chair and have a stranger look at my bare back without being filled with shame and self-doubt. Part of m

Out of the Darkess and into the Light

I haven't written in weeks… It hasn't been due to writer's block, but rather the fear of judgement. I've had all these topics floating around in my head but have stopped myself from sharing because I didn't want to alienate anyone or make them feel uncomfortable. Isn't that silly? Silly but true. Why are we so afraid to share our inner truths? I'm spending the week in a beautiful log home in northern Michigan with my family. All the cousins are together and there is constant chatter and laughter. The soundtrack of innocence and the essence of childhood. They are unapologetically authentic and vulnerable. Where along the spectrum of maturing did we learn to let the fear of judgment lead us to hide those parts of ourselves that we deem shameful, or "bad"? How did we develop a culture of perfection? One that values the image we project over the authenticity and rawness of our humanity? What if we celebrated our diversity beyond the colo

Broken Hearted

Last night some ghosts from the past rose up and it felt as if my heart was breaking all over again. I was so sad. Over a year ago, I remember feeling ready to lay down some of that grief I had been carrying for so long. Grace, time, healing and love had softened the edges of that grief and I was left with a gift. Grief had turned into acceptance, forgiveness and peace. And I realized what a treasure this grief had become. So many lessons learned from that experience. As scary as it was to sink into my grief and find my way through the sadness, I knew that somehow, this grief would always be a part of me. But last night I wasn't prepared for how quickly those old hurts could resurface. The ache was so familiar and deep that for a moment I wondered if I had indeed experienced any healing over the past years. It felt as if my heart was broken into a million tiny pieces... and then I realized, my heart had broken into a million tiny pieces at one point. The past 3 yea

brand new day

Search This Blog